ADHD proven to be a genetic disorder! Well, maybe not.

Medical News Today recently ran a headline stating “ADHD Is A Genetic Neurodevelopmental Disorder, Scientists Reveal.” They drew this headline from a recent study published in The Lancet, which analyzed the DNA of 366 children diagnosed with ADHD against a much larger control group. The study in The Lancet concluded that 15% of the ADHD sample had chunks of DNA missing or duplicated compared to 7% of the control group. This is a significant result, suggesting a probable genetic predisposition for some children with problems with inattention and impulsivity.
But it hardly justifies the headline nor the statement by Professor Anita Thapar, lead investigator of the study:
“Now we can say with confidence that ADHD is a genetic disease and that the brains of children with this condition develop differently to those of other children.”
In fact, if one looks closely at the numbers, a more accurate headline begins to take shape: “85% of ADHD cases found to have no genetic basis.” Admittedly, this is an over-simplification, as there may be other, hitherto undiscovered genetic markers implicated in impulsivity and inattention. However, if you consider the fact that the investigators in most studies of ADHD are more rigorous in their election process than clinicians, who often diagnose and prescribe stimulants for “subclinical” cases, the percentage of nongenetic impulsive/inattentive behavior is probably far higher than 85%. Not to mention that the headline and Professor Anita Thapar’s conclusion ignore the complex interaction between environment and heredity at the heart of nearly all psychological diagnoses. The fact that 7% of the “normal” population have the same genetic markers and no diagnostically significant symptoms suggests that DNA abnormalities are just pieces in a larger puzzle.
The problem is that spin in medical journals has a huge effect on clinical practice. You can be sure that pharmaceutical reps have incorporated the headlines, rather than the numbers, into their talking points. And how many pediatricians and psychiatrists look past these headlines to the nuanced results? CHADD, the largest ADHD patient advocacy group (largely funded by drug companies), now states in its website, without referencing specific studies:
“There is little question that heredity makes the largest contribution to the expression of [ADHD] in the population. “
The belief that ADHD is determined by genes invariably means that a child will be treated with stimulant medication rather than therapy. You don’t use words against a brain abnormality. The numbers bear this out. Global sales of ADHD drugs increase 8% year on year and are forecast to reach $4.3 billion by 2012. For the parent who consults with a doctor about a child’s impulsive behavior, caveat emptor.
Reader Comments (3)
Your essay was very good, in your articles I learned a lot. I'm honored to see such worthy of study of articles. This is the sea of knowledge. louis vuitton replica monogramouflage
Hey, your posts have inspired me! - I love the way you directly get to the point, and then work outwards. I’ve been trying to do figure out what I want to say about ,that would allow me to do exactly the same thing.
sex drugs
sex pills wholesale
sex pills
sex pills for women
female sex pills
woman's sex drive pills
male sex pills
sex delay spray
sex toys
adult sex toys
best sex toys
condom
female condom
condom sex
best condoms
Pilatory
weight loss products
best weight loss products
sex drive pills
best sex pills
top weight loss products
male sex endurance pills
best male sex pills
herbal sex pill
herbal sex pill for men
herbal sex pills for women
sex drugs
sex for drugs
sex and drugs
sex drugs Supplier
female sex drugs
sex on drugs
hippies drugs sex
drugs for sex
male sex drive reduction drugs
girls having sex for drugs
Herbal Sex drugs
herbal sex drugs for men
herbal sex drugs for women
Sex Delay Spray
sex toys
robot sex toys
big sex toys
Condoms
female condoms
used condoms
best condoms
Pilatory
Weight Loss Product
weight loss products
best weight loss products
top weight loss products
Sex Blue Pill
Blue Pills
Sex Blue Pill uk
Blue Pills Supplier
Blue Pills Manufacturer
Blue Pills Wholesaler
sex pill
sex pills
sex pills Supplier
sex pills Manufacturer
sex pills Wholesaler
sex pills Factory
uggs boots outlet
ugg outlet online
uggs outlet store
ugg factory outlet
ugg online outlet
uggs for sale
uggs boots on sale
ugg on sale
uggs on sale cheap
cheap uggs on sale